CIT(A) Appeal in India: First Appeal in Form 35 and Form No. 99

India, from Chennai+91 91760 44244

By CA V. Viswanathan, FCA, ACS, CFE, IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). V Viswanathan & Associates, Chartered Accountants, FRN 013713S. Law stated as at 18 November 2026.

A first appeal against an income-tax order is filed before the Commissioner (Appeals) or Joint Commissioner (Appeals) within 30 days of service, in Form 35 for assessment year 2026-27 and earlier, or Form No. 99 for tax year 2026-27 onwards. The government fee is ₹250 to ₹1,000. The appeal is admitted only if tax on the returned income has been paid, and most appeals are decided facelessly through the National Faceless Appeal Centre. V Viswanathan & Associates drafts and represents first appeals for clients across India from Chennai.

What is a first appeal before the CIT(A) or JCIT(A)?

A first appeal is the taxpayer's challenge to an order of the Assessing Officer, such as a scrutiny assessment under section 143(3), a reassessment, a best-judgment assessment under section 144 or a penalty. It is decided by the Commissioner (Appeals), or by the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) for the classes of smaller cases assigned to that authority. The orders that can be appealed are listed in sections 246 and 246A of the 1961 Act and sections 356 and 357 of the 2025 Act. Only the taxpayer can file a first appeal; the department cannot.

How is a first appeal filed, step by step?

Seven steps in a first appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals), from the date of service to the appellate order 1. Check the date of service The 30 days run from service, not from the order date 2. Pay tax on returned income Condition for admission: section 249(4) or 358(6) 3. Draft facts and grounds Statement of facts and numbered grounds of appeal 4. File online Form 35, or Form No. 99 under the 2025 Act, with the fee 5. Apply for stay of demand To the Assessing Officer, usually on paying 20% 6. Hearing notices and submissions Faceless; a video hearing can be requested 7. Appellate order Then the order giving effect, refund or further appeal
Steps in a first appeal.

What are the time limit, fee and conditions?

PointRule1961 Act2025 Act
FormFiled electronically and verified by the person who can sign the returnForm 35, Rule 45Form No. 99, Rule 167
Time limit30 days from service of the demand notice for an assessment or penalty; from service of the order in other casesSection 249(2)Section 358(3)
Fee₹250, ₹500 or ₹1,000 by assessed income; ₹250 in other mattersSection 249(1)Section 358(2)
Tax to be paid firstTax due on the returned income; or, if no return was filed, an amount equal to the advance tax payableSection 249(4)Section 358(6)
Relief from that conditionAvailable on application, for recorded reasons, only in the no-return caseProviso to section 249(4)Section 358(7)
Late appealMay be admitted if there was sufficient causeSection 249(3)Section 358(5)

How does the faceless appeal through the NFAC work?

Most first appeals are handled under the Faceless Appeal Scheme, 2021 by the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC). The appeal is allotted to an appeal unit without the taxpayer knowing the officer; notices arrive on the e-filing portal and replies are uploaded there. A hearing by video conference can be requested. Because there is no conversation across a table, the written submission has to carry the whole case: a chronology, each ground argued separately, the evidence referred to by page, and the decisions relied on.

Can new evidence be filed in the first appeal?

Yes, in limited cases. Rule 46A of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 allows additional evidence where the Assessing Officer refused to admit it, where the taxpayer was prevented by sufficient cause from producing it, or where the order was passed without a sufficient opportunity. This is the route after a best-judgment assessment under section 144 made because portal notices were missed. The evidence is sent to the Assessing Officer for a remand report, and the taxpayer may file a rejoinder to that report.

What can the Commissioner (Appeals) do with the order?

In an appeal against an assessment the authority may confirm, reduce, enhance or annul it; in a penalty appeal it may confirm, cancel or vary the penalty (section 251 of the 1961 Act; section 360 of the 2025 Act). An enhancement can be made only after giving the taxpayer an opportunity to show cause. Either side can take the appellate order to the Tribunal.

What if the deadline is a few days away?

File first and build later. The form needs the order details, the statement of facts and the grounds; detailed submissions and the paper book can follow when hearing notices issue. Send the order, the demand notice and proof of the date of service. Grounds can be added or revised later with the permission of the appellate authority, but a missed date needs a condonation application.

Can a pending appeal be taken over from another representative?

Yes. The taxpayer authorises the new representative on the e-filing portal and gives a fresh letter of authority. We then download the appeal record, the notices and the earlier submissions, and reply to the pending notice. Where a hearing notice is due within days, an adjournment request with reasons is filed at once.

What if the appeal has been pending for a long time?

The 1961 Act asks the first appellate authority to decide an appeal within one year from the end of the financial year of filing where possible (section 250(6A)), but this is not a binding limit. Where a large demand is blocking refunds or a stay is running out, a written request for early hearing, setting out the hardship, is filed in the appeal, and the stay is kept alive in the meantime.

Worked example: last date and fee

ItemWorkingResult
OrderAssessment for assessment year 2025-26; income assessed at ₹18,50,0001961 Act applies
Demand notice served3 December 2026
Last date3 December 2026 + 30 days2 January 2027
FeeAssessed income above ₹2,00,000₹1,000

How do you choose the best CA firm for a CIT(A) appeal?

No regulator ranks firms for appeal work. Judge a firm on these points.

  1. Who will appear. Ask for the name and qualification of the person who drafts the grounds and attends the hearing. Under section 288 of the 1961 Act (section 515 of the 2025 Act) a chartered accountant or an advocate may represent a taxpayer before the appellate authorities and the Tribunal.
  2. Fit with the dispute. An appeal about accounts, cash flows, valuation or a forensic trail turns on facts and working papers. An appeal about jurisdiction or the meaning of a section turns on law. Pick the representative whose daily work matches the point in dispute.
  3. Both Acts. Most appeals filed today are still under the 1961 Act, and new-Act disputes will follow. The representative should state which Act and form apply to your order before drafting.
  4. Written scope and fee. Get the scope, the fee and what is excluded in writing before work starts. The filing fee payable to the government is separate and is fixed by the Act.

How do we work?

CA V. Viswanathan is a Fellow Chartered Accountant (ICAI membership 228990), an Associate Company Secretary, a Certified Fraud Examiner and an IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). V Viswanathan & Associates has been in practice since 2012 and serves clients across India from Chennai. First appeals are faceless, so papers move online; consultations are by video, and Tribunal hearings are attended in person or by video, as the bench permits.

About V Viswanathan & Associates

  • Chartered Accountants, FRN 013713S— Practising since 2012 from G-131, Spencer Plaza, Anna Salai, Chennai.
  • IBBI Registered Valuer— Securities or financial assets, CA V. Viswanathan (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333), registered 30 September 2019.
  • FCA, ACS, CFE— Member of ICAI since 2012 and Fellow since 2017; company law, tax and forensic accounting in one practice.
  • Across India— Serves clients across India from Chennai through video consultations and digitally signed reports.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the time limit for a CIT(A) appeal?

Thirty days from service of the notice of demand for an assessment or penalty, and from service of the order in other cases: section 249(2) of the 1961 Act and section 358(3) of the 2025 Act.

What is the fee for filing Form 35?

Rs 250 where the assessed income is up to Rs 1,00,000, Rs 500 up to Rs 2,00,000, Rs 1,000 above that, and Rs 250 where the appeal is on another matter.

What is Form 99?

Form No. 99 is the form for an appeal to the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) or Commissioner (Appeals) under the Income-tax Act, 2025, prescribed by Rule 167 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026. It corresponds to Form 35 under the 1962 Rules.

Can the department file a first appeal?

No. Only the taxpayer can appeal to the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) or Commissioner (Appeals). The department can appeal to the Tribunal against the first appellate order.

Can I get a personal hearing in a faceless appeal?

A hearing by video conference can be requested under the Faceless Appeal Scheme, 2021. The written submission remains the main record.

Can I file documents that I did not give the Assessing Officer?

Only within Rule 46A: where the officer refused them, where you were prevented by sufficient cause, or where you were not given a sufficient opportunity. An application explaining the reason goes with the evidence.

Do I need to pay the whole demand to file the appeal?

No. Only the tax on the income you returned must be paid. For the disputed demand you apply to the Assessing Officer to be treated as not in default while the appeal is pending.

Which is the best CA for a CIT(A) appeal?

There is no official ranking. Choose on who will personally draft and appear, experience with the kind of addition in your order, and a written scope and fee.

Related Guides

Income-Tax Appeals in India

Forums, time limits, fees and forms under both Acts.

ITAT Appeal

Form 36 and Form 115, cross-objections, stay and rectification.

Stay of Demand

How recovery is held back while an appeal is pending.

Condonation of Delay

Filing an appeal after the time limit has passed.

Income Tax Appeal Consultant in Chennai

Our Chennai page for first appeals and Tribunal work.

Share Valuation for Income Tax (Rule 57)

Fair market value of unquoted shares on a transfer.

Law stated as at 18 November 2026. Official sources: section 358, section 362, section 363, section 536, Income-tax Act, 2025, Form No. 99 guidance note. This page is general information, not advice on a specific transaction.

First Appeal Before the CIT(A)

Send the order, the demand notice and the date of service. We will confirm the last date and what the grounds should cover.