GST and Income-Tax Appeals Together: Keeping the Facts Consistent
By CA V. Viswanathan, FCA, ACS, CFE, IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). V Viswanathan & Associates, Chartered Accountants, FRN 013713S. Law stated as at 18 November 2026.
A GST demand and an income-tax addition often arise from the same facts: a turnover mismatch or disputed purchases. The GST first appeal is filed within three months under section 107 of the CGST Act with a 10% pre-deposit; the income-tax first appeal within 30 days. Running them on one reconciliation and one statement of facts avoids contradictory positions. V Viswanathan & Associates handles both for clients across India from Chennai.
Why do GST and income-tax disputes arrive together?
The two departments exchange data. A turnover difference between GST returns and the income-tax return, input tax credit claimed on invoices from a supplier later found to be non-existent, or a survey by one department can each lead to notices from both. The facts are the same; the laws, forums and time limits are not.
How do the two appeal systems compare?
| Point | GST | Income tax |
|---|---|---|
| First appeal | Appellate Authority, section 107 of the CGST Act | Commissioner (Appeals) or Joint Commissioner (Appeals) |
| Time limit | Three months from the order, plus one month on sufficient cause | 30 days, with condonation for sufficient cause |
| Payment to file | Admitted amount plus 10% of the disputed tax | Tax on returned income; 20% of the disputed demand is the usual condition for stay |
| Second appeal | GST Appellate Tribunal, section 112 | Income Tax Appellate Tribunal |
| Typical addition | Tax on suppressed turnover; reversal of input tax credit | Suppressed sales; bogus purchases; unexplained expenditure under section 69C |
What goes wrong when the two are run separately?
- A turnover figure is admitted in one reply and disputed in the other
- A reconciliation given to one department contradicts the books produced to the other
- A statement made in a GST investigation is used in the income-tax assessment without being answered there
- The shorter income-tax time limit is missed while the GST appeal is being prepared
- The same receipt is taxed as turnover under GST and as unexplained credit under income tax, and neither appeal points this out
How should both be handled?
Our GST appeal work is described on the GST appeal consultant in Chennai page, and the income-tax stages on the income-tax appeals in India page.
How do we work?
CA V. Viswanathan is a Fellow Chartered Accountant (ICAI membership 228990), an Associate Company Secretary, a Certified Fraud Examiner and an IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). V Viswanathan & Associates has been in practice since 2012 and serves clients across India from Chennai. First appeals are faceless, so papers move online; consultations are by video, and Tribunal hearings are attended in person or by video, as the bench permits.
About V Viswanathan & Associates
- Chartered Accountants, FRN 013713S— Practising since 2012 from G-131, Spencer Plaza, Anna Salai, Chennai.
- IBBI Registered Valuer— Securities or financial assets, CA V. Viswanathan (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333), registered 30 September 2019.
- FCA, ACS, CFE— Member of ICAI since 2012 and Fellow since 2017; company law, tax and forensic accounting in one practice.
- Across India— Serves clients across India from Chennai through video consultations and digitally signed reports.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the income-tax department use a GST order against me?
It can use it as information. The findings are not binding in the income-tax proceeding, and they have to be answered there on the evidence.
Which appeal has the shorter time limit?
Income tax: 30 days for the first appeal, against three months under section 107 of the CGST Act.
How much has to be paid to file each appeal?
For GST, the admitted amount and 10% of the disputed tax. For income tax, the tax on returned income; a stay of the disputed demand usually needs 20% of it.
Can one firm handle both appeals?
Yes. A chartered accountant can represent a taxpayer before the appellate authorities under both laws, and handling both keeps the facts consistent.
What if the same amount is taxed under both laws?
GST on turnover and income tax on profit are different levies, but an addition of the whole receipt as unexplained income, when it is already recorded as turnover, should be challenged as double taxation of the same sum.
Related Guides
Unexplained Credits and Penny-Stock Additions
Sections 68 to 69C and the 78% tax under section 115BBE.
Law stated as at 18 November 2026. Official sources: section 358, section 362, section 363, section 536, Income-tax Act, 2025, Form No. 99 guidance note. This page is general information, not advice on a specific transaction.
GST and Income-Tax Notices Together
Send both orders and the returns for the year. We will prepare one reconciliation for both appeals.