Share Valuation Disputes in Income-Tax Appeals and the Valuer's Rebuttal Report

India, from Chennai+91 91760 44244

By CA V. Viswanathan, FCA, ACS, CFE, IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). V Viswanathan & Associates, Chartered Accountants, FRN 013713S. Law stated as at 18 November 2026.

Share valuation is disputed in income-tax assessments under section 56(2)(viib) for years up to assessment year 2024-25, and under sections 56(2)(x) and 50CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (sections 92(2)(m) and 79 of the 2025 Act), with fair market value computed under Rule 11UA or Rule 57. Most additions arise because the officer rejects the method or compares projections with later results. V Viswanathan & Associates prepares registered valuer rebuttal reports and represents the appeal, for clients across India from Chennai.

Which provisions bring share valuation into a tax assessment?

Situation1961 Act2025 ActWho is taxed
Shares issued above fair market value by a closely held companySection 56(2)(viib); does not apply from assessment year 2025-26No corresponding chargeThe issuing company, for earlier years only
Shares received for less than fair market valueSection 56(2)(x)Section 92(2)(m)The recipient, where the shortfall exceeds ₹50,000
Unquoted shares sold below fair market valueSection 50CASection 79The seller, on the deemed consideration
How fair market value is computedRule 11UA, Income-tax Rules, 1962Rule 57, Income-tax Rules, 2026

Section 56(2)(viib), often called angel tax, was withdrawn by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024 and does not apply from assessment year 2025-26. It remains in dispute only for earlier years that are under assessment or appeal.

Why do valuation additions arise?

  • The officer compares projections in a discounted cash flow report with later actual results and rejects the report.
  • The officer replaces the method chosen by the taxpayer with net asset value.
  • The report is not from the person the rule requires, or is dated after the transaction.
  • Inputs such as growth rate, discount rate or terminal value are held to be unsupported.
  • The valuation date in the report differs from the date the rule fixes.

What does a registered valuer's rebuttal report contain?

Six steps in preparing a registered valuer rebuttal report for a share valuation dispute 1. Read the order and the original report List each objection the officer has raised 2. Fix the valuation date Use only information available on that date 3. Support each input Growth, margins, discount rate and terminal value, with sources 4. Reconcile projections with actuals Explain variances by events after the valuation date 5. Cross-check with a second method And show the sensitivity of the value 6. Report for the appellate authority Signed, with working papers as annexures
Preparing a valuation rebuttal for an appeal.

A valuation is an estimate made on a date, with what was known on that date. The strongest answer to a hindsight comparison is a record showing that each assumption was reasonable when made. Where the report under attack was prepared by another valuer, an independent review by a registered valuer addresses the officer's objections one by one. Where additional evidence is needed in the first appeal, it is filed under Rule 46A with reasons.

Can the valuer be penalised?

Section 271J allows a penalty of ₹10,000 on an accountant, merchant banker or registered valuer for each report or certificate in which incorrect information is furnished. The order is appealable to the Commissioner (Appeals). A difference of professional judgment on an assumption is not, by itself, incorrect information.

How do we work?

CA V. Viswanathan is a Fellow Chartered Accountant (ICAI membership 228990), an Associate Company Secretary, a Certified Fraud Examiner and an IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). V Viswanathan & Associates has been in practice since 2012 and serves clients across India from Chennai. First appeals are faceless, so papers move online; consultations are by video, and Tribunal hearings are attended in person or by video, as the bench permits.

About V Viswanathan & Associates

  • Chartered Accountants, FRN 013713S— Practising since 2012 from G-131, Spencer Plaza, Anna Salai, Chennai.
  • IBBI Registered Valuer— Securities or financial assets, CA V. Viswanathan (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333), registered 30 September 2019.
  • FCA, ACS, CFE— Member of ICAI since 2012 and Fellow since 2017; company law, tax and forensic accounting in one practice.
  • Across India— Serves clients across India from Chennai through video consultations and digitally signed reports.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does angel tax under section 56(2)(viib) still apply?

No. It does not apply from assessment year 2025-26. It is relevant only to earlier years still under assessment or appeal.

Can the Assessing Officer reject a DCF valuation because actual results were lower?

Officers do so, and it is a common ground of appeal. A valuation is tested on what was known on the valuation date, and later results are not by themselves a reason to reject it.

What is a valuation rebuttal report?

An independent report by a registered valuer that answers each objection in the assessment order, supports the inputs with sources as on the valuation date, and cross-checks the value with a second method.

Which rule computes fair market value of unquoted shares?

Rule 11UA of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 for earlier years, and Rule 57 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 under the 2025 Act.

Who can prepare the rebuttal report?

CA V. Viswanathan is an IBBI Registered Valuer for Securities or Financial Assets (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333) and a chartered accountant, and prepares such reports for use in appeals.

Related Guides

Income-Tax Appeals in India

Forums, time limits, fees and forms under both Acts.

Share Valuation for Income Tax (Rule 57)

Fair market value of unquoted shares on a transfer.

First Appeal: CIT(A), JCIT(A) and NFAC

Form 35 and Form 99, the 30-day limit and faceless hearings.

ITAT Appeal

Form 36 and Form 115, cross-objections, stay and rectification.

Income-Tax Penalty Appeals

Sections 270A, 270AA, 271(1)(c) and 271J.

Valuation Services in India

Valuation reports by purpose and signatory.

Law stated as at 18 November 2026. Official sources: section 358, section 362, section 363, section 536, Income-tax Act, 2025, Form No. 99 guidance note. This page is general information, not advice on a specific transaction.

Valuation Addition

Send the assessment order and the valuation report it rejects. We will list what a rebuttal must answer.