Transfer Pricing Appeals Through the DRP, Foreign-Payment TDS Disputes and NRI Appeals
By CA V. Viswanathan, FCA, ACS, CFE, IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). V Viswanathan & Associates, Chartered Accountants, FRN 013713S. Law stated as at 18 November 2026.
A transfer pricing adjustment reaches the taxpayer as a draft assessment order under section 144C of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Within 30 days the taxpayer either files objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel in Form 35A, and then appeals the final order directly to the Tribunal in Form 36B, or waits for the final order and appeals to the Commissioner (Appeals). Disputes on tax deducted from foreign payments turn on section 195 and the treaty. V Viswanathan & Associates handles these appeals for clients across India from Chennai.
What is the route from a transfer pricing adjustment to the Tribunal?
Dispute Resolution Panel or Commissioner (Appeals)?
| Point | Dispute Resolution Panel | Commissioner (Appeals) |
|---|---|---|
| When chosen | Objections within 30 days of the draft order | No objections filed; appeal after the final order |
| Demand | Arises only with the final order, after the directions | Arises at once with the final order |
| Time | Directions within nine months from the end of the month of the draft order | No binding time limit |
| Next forum | Tribunal, directly | Tribunal, after the first appellate order |
| Department's appeal | The department cannot appeal against the directions | The department can appeal to the Tribunal |
Section numbers on this page are those of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which continues to govern orders for assessment year 2026-27 and earlier under section 536(2)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 2025. The 2025 Act carries the same subject under new section numbers for tax year 2026-27 onwards.
What is usually in dispute?
- Selection and rejection of comparable companies
- The most appropriate method and the profit level indicator
- Adjustments for working capital, risk and capacity
- Whether a transaction is an international transaction at all, for example advertising spend or guarantees
- Interest on delayed receivables and on loans to associated enterprises
How are disputes on tax deduction from foreign payments handled?
Section 195 requires tax to be deducted from a payment to a non-resident only if the sum is chargeable to tax in India. Disputes arise when the officer treats a payment as royalty or fees for technical services under section 9(1)(vi) or (vii), holds the payer in default under section 201, or disallows the expense under section 40(a)(i). The answer usually lies in the tax treaty, which prevails where it is more favourable to the taxpayer (section 90(2)). On software, the Supreme Court held in Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence (P) Ltd. v. CIT (2021) 432 ITR 471 that payments to foreign suppliers for the use or resale of computer software under end-user or distribution agreements are not royalty under the treaties considered. For payments to residents the parallel provisions are section 194J for professional and technical fees and the disallowance under section 40(a)(ia), and in every case the expense must first qualify as business expenditure under section 37. The orders are appealed to the Commissioner (Appeals) and then the Tribunal.
How does a non-resident run an appeal from abroad?
First appeals are faceless and filed online, so presence in India is not needed. The non-resident authorises a representative, and treaty relief is supported with a tax residency certificate from the home country and Form 10F. Refunds are issued to a validated bank account. Where the dispute is about residential status, travel records and the day count under section 6 are the core evidence.
How do we work?
CA V. Viswanathan is a Fellow Chartered Accountant (ICAI membership 228990), an Associate Company Secretary, a Certified Fraud Examiner and an IBBI Registered Valuer (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333). V Viswanathan & Associates has been in practice since 2012 and serves clients across India from Chennai. First appeals are faceless, so papers move online; consultations are by video, and Tribunal hearings are attended in person or by video, as the bench permits.
About V Viswanathan & Associates
- Chartered Accountants, FRN 013713S— Practising since 2012 from G-131, Spencer Plaza, Anna Salai, Chennai.
- IBBI Registered Valuer— Securities or financial assets, CA V. Viswanathan (IBBI/RV/03/2019/12333), registered 30 September 2019.
- FCA, ACS, CFE— Member of ICAI since 2012 and Fellow since 2017; company law, tax and forensic accounting in one practice.
- Across India— Serves clients across India from Chennai through video consultations and digitally signed reports.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the time limit to file objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel?
Thirty days from receipt of the draft assessment order, in Form 35A.
Can I appeal directly to the ITAT after the DRP directions?
Yes. The final assessment order passed on the directions of the Panel is appealed directly to the Tribunal, in Form 36B.
Can the department appeal against DRP directions?
No. The directions bind the Assessing Officer and the department has no appeal against them.
When is tax deductible under section 195?
Only where the sum paid to the non-resident is chargeable to tax in India, after applying the tax treaty where it is more favourable.
Can an NRI contest an income-tax order without coming to India?
Yes. The appeal is filed and heard online through an authorised representative.
Related Guides
Law stated as at 18 November 2026. Official sources: section 358, section 362, section 363, section 536, Income-tax Act, 2025, Form No. 99 guidance note. This page is general information, not advice on a specific transaction.
Transfer Pricing or Section 195 Dispute
Send the draft or final order and the transfer pricing study. We will advise on the Panel or the appeal route.